The definition of magic.

The definition of magic.

When starting to develop your interest in Witchcraft, a discussion on the nature of magic seems like a pretty good place to start.

Defining something that you intend to incorporate into your life in a significant way seems an obvious starting topic, but doing so has proven notoriously difficult. Vested interests have deliberately tried to make the term ‘magic’ as nebulous as possible in an effort to avoid any actual thought on the subject.

Equally frustrating, but perhaps a bit more excusable, is that many definitions are based on a misunderstanding of Crowley’s attempt so, I suppose, it’d be prudent to start there.

This was his working definition:

‘Magick is the science and art of causing change in conformity with the Will’.

From here, a lot of modern witches and warlocks have essentially boiled this down to mean that you effect change with the conscious will. Now, obviously, this reduces everything into an act of magic which, while stupid, is quite deliberate. In collusion with the nefarious influence of modern ‘culture’, some modern magic folk like the idea of saying everything is an act of magic. This isn’t because it’s true; rather it’s because it’s supposed to imply that everyone is, by proxy, a witch or warlock… Whether they want to be one or not.

The reason this is bollocks, is because it removes the aspect of choice.

The Dark Neopagan author, Konstantinos, effectively modified the definition in his Nocturnal Witchcraft series in order to clear up some of this confusion. He added a qualifier to the end of Crowley’s definition which, when paraphrased, added the following line to the end:

‘… in ways that would otherwise be unchangeable’.

This seems like a reasonable reform, and it does get rid of the absurd ‘everyone’s a witch’ angle. But as a working definition, it’s scarcely an improvement – it doesn’t resolve properly because it doesn’t define the ‘otherwise’. Because witches and warlocks deal so heavily with this ‘otherwise’, it’s an important aspect to nail down properly! What Konstantinos also doesn’t achieve is to clear up the misunderstanding that properly trained occultists are tearing their hair out at my failure to address yet.

To understand Crowley’s definition of magic, you need to first understand his magical system and the very specific choice of words. Going through this bit by bit is worthwhile.

Pinky swear.

‘Magick is the science and art…’

Okay, so, note the ‘k’ – Crowley was the first to use this suffix, in an attempt to differentiate his practice from the illusions of a card-sharp. This means he’s specifically talking about his own system, and we know that it was a more rigid version of occultism than most witches and warlocks would be comfortable with today. His time with Freemasonry and the Golden Dawn, prior to him forming the Abbey of Thelema, are a clear enough indication of what this tradition was.

thelema_ceremony_01

Secondly, Crowley described magic as both a science AND an art, two practices that are opposites to one another. Even universities split their degrees up in accordance with the delta. Science is the practice of proving absolutes via experiments with repeatable and observable results. Art, on the other hand, is about freedom of expression and relaying your personal interpretation of perfection.

But are the two compatible?

Well, yes; in this context, they are. Self-expression through ritual approach is an artistic endeavour, but those rituals should have predictable, prescribed and repeatable results. Crowley is saying that his system does this and, thus, that his definition of such is justified. But what of the second half of his definition?

‘… of causing change in conformity with the Will’.

Witchcraft already has issues with the first half of the definition, but the second looks clear enough – change things to be the way you will, or want, them to be. Easy-peasy. Except Crowley wasn’t talking about the conscious will that modern witches and warlocks are talking about. He’s describing the subconscious or ‘true’ will, the will of the soul or spirit and its alchemical attempt to reconnect with divinity. It’s an invocation of a deep issue relating to philosophy and spirituality (which he expands upon in ‘The Book of the Law’), not an attempt to pay the rent or get a bit more cash to buy a car.

And if you want me to abridge my point?

It’s that simply using Crowley’s definition, without understanding what he was talking about, is pointless. Let’s be clear about why.

First of all, Witchcraft isn’t a science. At all. It’s not interested in prescribed, repeatable results – it’s interested in freedom of expression and leaving results in the hands of the balance factor. It’s about creating your own spells and rituals, using your own pantheons and traditions, and utilising what inspires you most at any given stage. It is of course, therefore, an art and a means of self-indulgence.

Secondly, Witchcraft is far more interested in working with divinity than many of its modern practitioners are willing to accept. In our unique appreciation of the Summerland, we can fully aggregate the nature of reality with what we want out of it. Self-development is absolutely fundamental in magic, because that’s the only way to make change permanent rather than merely superficial.

Feel free to ignore those who are talking about ‘spells for a new car’. This laughable approach is the sign of the chump, hobbyist or magical tourist. It’s right to ridicule it. Only in becoming better people, with better ambitions and relationships, can the magical life of Witchcraft really have meaning. It’s this goal, to fulfill a destiny of your choosing, that should preoccupy your magical workings.

possessing_my_destiny

So do we, as members of the Aeonic tradition, have a better definition of magic?

As it so happens, yes, I believe so. Try this on for size:

‘Magic is the art of causing internal change, in order to influence external events’.

Believe me when I tell you this: becoming the person you want to be, with the right immediate reality, makes all the other tumblers of the magical combination lock fall into place. Becoming what you want attracts what you need. Happiness or success aren’t goals, they’re side effects of living a fulfilling life or applying the right systems.

All other attempts at superficial change are doomed to abject failure.

Source: The definition of magic.

By GrannyMoon Posted in Pagan

One comment on “The definition of magic.

  1. For what it’s worth, I got my degree from the “College of Arts and Sciences” at the State University of New York at Buffalo. So all universities do not split art & science. But I see your point.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Smorgasbord Blog Magazine

Blog magazine for lovers of health, food, books, music, humour and life in general

Holistica2be

Living in harmony with "All that is"

Rubys Readings

Psychic, Astrologer, Healer, & Blogger

A Gray Witch's Grimoire

⍟The Nocturnal Cauldron⍟ https://thenocturnalcauldron.ning.com

Whimsical Moon Farm

Whimsical Moon Farm is a cozy nook in the countryside where we make hand-crafted herbal soaps with home-grown herbs.

GrannyMoon's Morning Feast

GoddessSchool.com ~ Healing Arts and Pagan Studies

Teagan's Books

Now available: "Atonement in Bloom"

Positive Side Of The Coin

Not just live and let live, but live and help live

Walking with a Smacked Pentax

A photographic journey through the North of England, Scotland and Wales

Roberta Writes

How you see life depends on how you look at things

Paul Militaru

Photography Portfolio

Iain Kelly

Fiction Writing

CynthiaBaileyRug

From The Desk Of Cynthia Bailey-Rug...

Awakening the Witch

Waking Up at the Eleventh Hour

Good Witches Homestead

Enchanted World of Magical Gardening ~ Crystals & Gemstones ~ Locally Grown Organic Herbs

SoundEagle 🦅ೋღஜஇ

Where The Eagles Fly . . . . Art Science Poetry Music & Ideas

Sun in Gemini

SteveTanham - writing, mysticism, photography, poetry, friends

Perception

feelings, thoughts and dilemmas

Hestia's Servant

Living the Life of Magick and Devotion

wiccanhighpriestess

Rev. Brooke J Burke, HPs, MScB. All Rights Reserved.

koolkosherkitchen

Welcome to my Kool Kosher Kitchen where food is fun and fun is to create food!

The Vulpine Portfolio

Paranormal Author. Freelance Magickian. Occult Historian. Modern Necromancer. Lilith Devotee. Lovecraft Geek.

blackwings666

Horror, Science Fiction, Comic Books and More

Ozark Superstitions, Magic, and Folklore

The Musings of a Hillybilly Goomer Doctor

bluebird of bitterness

The opinions expressed are those of the author. You go get your own opinions.

Chris The Story Reading Ape's Blog

READER - WRITER - RESOURCES - & MORE

Pujakins

From the Poet's Heart

Elder Mountain Dreaming

Ptaki Mądrości (Birds of Wisdom) Dreaming, Lunar Cycles, Soul Healing, Creative Emotional Work, Journeys, Mirrorism, Sacred Art

The Eldrum Tree

Living a Mythic Life in the Modern Age

But I Smile Anyway...

Musings and memories, words and wisdom... of a working family woman

witchlike

Exploring wise-craft and weirdness

Sentient Witch

Sentient Witchcraft

The Barefoot Aya

Resilience in Natural Healthcare

Anima Mundi Crystals

Unique Handmade Crystals Jewelry

OVER THE HILL on the YELLOW BRICK ROAD

Growing older with silliness, high spirits and a lot of heart.

France & Vincent

Writing Magic, Myth and Mystery

4cats Blog

Great Cat Toys and Cat Health Topics

Discover

A daily selection of the best content published on WordPress, collected for you by humans who love to read.

DNAeXplained - Genetic Genealogy

Discovering Your Ancestors - One Gene at a Time

The Foxhole

Unapologetic Patriot

The Purple Almond

Food for the body, mind and soul

Yarn Spells

Crafts and Ramblings of a Disenchanted Cradle Witch

anita dawes and jaye marie

words, glorious words...

Life Is An Adventure

Explore Places You Never Been

%d bloggers like this: